Vagabond Synth Nerd’s Journal Vol. 257 - A Minor Instrument? The Maestro Who Made the Harmonica Into A Major Instrument Part I

The Harmonica... An Instrument I Didn’t Like—

In my previous piece, I wrote about the unexpected contrast between commercially successful music and more sophisticated music, sharing some of my personal thoughts as well.
This time, I would like to explore the world of music through the lens of an often-overlooked instrument: the harmonica.

Back in elementary school, I was part of the instrumental music club. The instrument I played? The most modest of them all — the harmonica.
To be specific, it was a tremolo harmonica (also known as a double-reed harmonica), which has two reeds for each note.

Honestly, I didn’t like the harmonica very much. Playing the same notes in unison with a group felt dull — maybe I simply wasn’t interested in doing the same thing as everyone else. I also had a kind of resistance to the sound itself. I assumed the harmonica produced a flat, featureless tone — a misunderstanding born from my own immaturity.
It wasn’t just the performers; none of the instructors ever taught us the true appeal of the harmonica or how to play it properly.
Moreover, at the time, I didn’t particularly like music all that much to begin with. Looking back now, I honestly don’t even remember why I joined the instrumental music club. Most likely, it was just because a friend invited me. That’s how distant music felt to me back then.
Later on, my relationship with music evolved — from acoustic guitar to synthesizers and other keyboard instruments — and after many twists and turns, I eventually encountered a certain harmonica player.
When I heard their performance, it was truly an eye-opening experience.

The Man Who Brought Color to Music with the Harmonica: Toots Thielemans

The first time I heard Toots Thielemans was, if I remember correctly, on Quincy Jones’s album The Dude. When I listened to the track “Velas” on that album, I was left speechless by the expressive power of the harmonica. That was Toots Thielemans.

Toots Thielemans was a harmonica player born in Belgium and a leading figure in the world of jazz. He was constantly sought after by top-tier artists such as Quincy Jones, Bill Evans, and Jaco Pastorius.
His harmonica stands apart from any other instrument. It’s no exaggeration to say that no one had imagined the harmonica could command such presence. His harmonica was full of brilliance, a one-of-a-kind sound that cut to the very core of music. And his greatest weapon was his overwhelming sense of “melancholy.” Toots Thielemans was a rare musician who could freely express a wide spectrum of emotional sorrow.
He participated in countless albums, leaving us with an unforgettable and powerful presence.

■ Recommended Album: Jaco Pastorius – Word of Mouth (1981)

This album showcases bassist Jaco Pastorius not just as a performer, but as an arranger with a broad, overarching vision of the entire work. Including arrangements for brass and strings, the album highlights Jaco’s identity as a complete musician, not merely a bassist.
From this perspective, Jaco shone a spotlight on harmonica player Toots Thielemans. It’s widely acknowledged that Toots is one of the central figures of this album.
Amid the ocean of layered sounds, the occasional appearance of Jaco’s fretless bass elevates the album to something truly one-of-a-kind. At the same time, Toots’s harmonica emerging from within that ensemble is also something that can only be described as unique.

Recommended Track: "Three Views of a Secret"

This track is a reimagined version of a song originally featured on Weather Report’s classic album Night Passage, reconstructed as a solo piece by Jaco Pastorius. While Jaco plays electric bass, he also handles acoustic piano and synthesizer.
The lineup includes powerhouse musicians such as Toots Thielemans (harmonica) and Jack DeJohnette (drums), along with the Word of Mouth Big Band.
The highlight of this track is undoubtedly Toots Thielemans’s harmonica.
From the original melody played by Wayne Shorter and Joe Zawinul, Toots miraculously extracts a beautiful new theme to perform. His expressive power is nothing short of breathtaking. The melancholic tone he creates is something only a harmonica can convey, and there is no doubt that the star of this piece is his harmonica.

■ Recommended Album: Bill Evans – Affinity (1979)

This is a timeless jazz masterpiece where the jazz piano maestro Bill Evans faced off with the harmonica virtuoso Toots Thielemans.
Many might wonder if jazz and harmonica really go together.
However, Toots Thielemans effortlessly blows away such doubts.
The essence of jazz lies in musicians inspiring each other to create music together. This album is a perfect example of that. Bill Evans’s piano playing, inspired by Toots’s emotional harmonica, takes on an unusually expressive and emotional character. It’s rare to hear his typically lyrical piano sound this emotional because Bill Evans’s coolness is part of his charm. Perhaps what he sought was that melancholic color that he himself did not possess.
It may well have been Toots Thielemans’s harmonica that broke through that side of Bill Evans and revealed a new aspect of him.
You can enjoy exquisite ballads like Paul Simon’s “I Do It for Your Love” and “‘Jesus’ Last Ballad”, “Days of Wine and Roses”, “Body and Soul”, and “Blue in Green” from an entirely different perspective.

Recommended Track: "Blue in Green"

This track comes from Miles Davis’s timeless jazz masterpiece of an album, Kind of Blue. There is a story that the piece, originally composed by pianist Bill Evans, was rewritten and credited to Miles himself.
It is no exaggeration to say that Toots Thielemans’s harmonica opened a new chapter in jazz with this song.
While Miles’s trumpet in the original is lyrical, Toots’s harmonica in this version carries a presence that even surpasses Miles’s. This is likely because he succeeded in adding a new shade of melancholy distinct from Miles’s own.

Musicians, albums, and recommended tracks covered this time:

• Artists: Toots Thielemans, Jaco Pastorius, Bill Evans, Miles Davis, and others
• Albums: Word of Mouth, Affinity
• Recommended tracks: “Three Views of a Secret”, “Blue in Green”

The “sound & person” column is made up of contributions from you.
For details about contributing, click here.